Grandma’s Banana Split Dessert Recipe

As summer approaches, so do summer picnics, potlucks, and family gatherings. This is the perfectly light tasting recipe which is perfect for a summer afternoon dessert. It’s called ‘Banana Split Dessert’ because that’s what it tastes like. The vanilla cream filling with the bananas, pineapple, whipped cream, ahhh.  So amazing.


I haven’t made this recipe in probably 10 years, I have no idea why. I have such fond memories of this recipe. It is a simple recipe which sits in the refrigerator until ready to serve. Perfect to make a day in advance for a summer afternoon party.  I gave it to my son for the first time (that he can remember) and he said it’s the best dessert he’s ever had.  Well, he can be a sweetie, but he was serious. The first bite of this recipe will have you smiling and digging in for more.

Grandma's Banana Split Dessert by Dish Ditty

Grandma’s Banana Split Dessert by Dish Ditty

I have no idea the origin of the recipe other than it was given to my mom by her mom, my Grandma. As I said in the notes of the recipe, my mom’s recipe said ‘margarine’, but that’s what all her recipes said from the 80’s. That’s what we used then, everyone thought it was healthier than butter (but we were definitely wrong). So, I put it back to butter, which I’m sure was the original recipe since my Grandma would not have had access to margarine when this recipe was handed down.

The light version is described in the notes. I know my parents used that recipe most of the time and it was good.  So, you can choose full fat or light, either way, it’s a fun recipe to serve to your friends and family.

And yes, I know, it has raw eggs.  I think I’ll try creating a version of this without the raw eggs, but the filling really is unique and I know that’s from the way the eggs, butter and sugar are beaten for 20 minutes to create a light and fluffy buttery and creamy filling. Ok, dive in!

Banana Split Dessert

Serves 12-16
Prep time 30 minutes
By author Dish Ditty

Ingredients

Crust

  • 2 cups Graham Crackers
  • 1/4lb Butter (melted)

Filling

  • 2 cups Powdered Sugar
  • 1/2lb Butter (softened)
  • 2 Eggs
  • 1 teaspoon Vanilla

Topping

  • 7 Bananas (cut lengthwise)
  • 4 cups Crushed Pineapples (drained - 2 cans)
  • 16oz Cool Whip (or Whipped Cream)
  • 1 cup Walnuts (chopped)
  • 1/2 cube Maraschino Cherries (drained, cut in half - 1 jar)

Note

Passed down from my Grandma (Mom's side).  The recipe written in my mom's cookbook had 'margarine', but I'm pretty sure margarine wasn't around when this recipe was created.  I used butter and it was perfect. Yes, this uses raw eggs, sorry about that, but it really is amazing.

My Mom Cherri's Modifications: To lighten this recipe, use a light butter flavored spread (check the trans fats, suggestions: Earth Balance, Olivio or Smart Balance), use 4 ounces of egg beaters instead of the eggs, and use Cool Whip Lite  Those three changes will reduce the calories in half and the fat by about 30%. Reducing the sugar on this recipe is a little more difficult.

Directions

Filling
Step 1
Cream the powdered sugar and the softened butter. Add the eggs and vanilla and beat for 20 minutes. While the filling is beating, make the crust and drain the cherries and crushed pineapples.
Crust
Step 2
Mix the graham crackers and the melted butter together and press on the bottom of a 9 X 13 inch pan. To create an even crust, use a metal measuring cup to press the graham crackers down.
Topping
Step 3
Spread the batter evenly onto the graham cracker crust. Then layer the sliced bananas, crushed pineapple and Cool Whip. Sprinkle with the chopped nuts, place the cherries on top and refrigerate for at least 1 hour.
Step 4
Slice & Serve!

1 Reply to "Grandma's Banana Split Dessert Recipe"

  • comment-avatar
    kelly October 5, 2016 (11:34 am)

    Yes very good but a little different is mine, we use box of vanilla cookies crushed instead of graham crackers we also add mini choc chips. we layer with 1/2 the pineapple on bottom then egg mixture then rest of pineapple and bananas. dont use walnuts but sundae nuts that you would buy prepackaged at store like the ones from mcdonalds.

Leave a reply

Your email address will not be published.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.